Casper Dream vs DreamCloud Premier

Trying to choose between the Casper Dream vs DreamCloud Premier? Both have a hybrid construction that combine foam and coil support systems, but their feel and comfort are different. The Casper Dream feels cooler, more balanced, and more responsive, while the DreamCloud Premier feels softer and more pressure relieving. In this hands-on comparison, we break down cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation and value to help you decide which mattress is the better fit.

Mattress Millionaires Quick Verdict: Casper Dream vs DreamCloud Premier

After sleeping on both mattresses for 3 nights, we crown the Casper Dream as the winner overall for its balanced feel, stronger cooling, better responsiveness and better comfort and support across stomach, back and combination sleep positions.

The DreamCloud Premier also has its merits and is the better value for plush pressure relief. Overall, it is a better choice for side sleepers, couples who need very good motion isolation, and anyone who wants a plush, Euro-top feel without spending luxury showroom prices.

Here is a quick breakdown of how each mattress performed during our testing:

The bottom line: the Casper Dream is the better all-around mattress and wins on support, bounce, cooling and multiple sleep positions. The DreamCloud Premier wins on pressure relief, motion isolation, plushness, policies and value.

• Choose Casper Dream if you want a cooler hybrid that feels balances and easy to move on.
• Choose DreamCloud Premier if you want a softer pillow top with deeper pressure relief and a better price to quality ratio.

If you are interested in a mattress with a memory foam feel and even deeper contouring, read our comparison of the Casper Dream vs Nectar Premier.

How We Tested the Casper Dream and DreamCloud Premier

At Mattress Millionaires, we evaluate every mattress through hands-on testing in our home sleep lab. For this comparison we:

• Slept on each mattress for at least 3 nights
• Slept on each mattress in the side, back, and stomach sleeping positions
• Observed cooling performance using a surface temperature test after 30 minutes of rest
• Compared motion transfer using a 10-lb drop test
• Assessed edge support by sitting and lying near the perimeter

Construction and Materials Comparison

Casper Dream = cooling top + zoned lumbar support + lifted pocketed coil system

The Casper Dream is 11.5 inches thick with layers that include a cooling cover that feels like knit jersey, memory foam comfort and support layers , and individually wrapped coils for responsive support. The standout design feature is the “Zoned Support” layer that is firmer through the center of the mattress to help keep the spine neutral by lifting the hips and lower back. This makes the mattress feel structured and supportive instead of melty and contouring.

If you want a deeper breakdown of its construction, firmness and hands-on testing notes, read our full Casper Dream mattress review.

DreamCloud Premier = cashmere blend quilted topper + foam + individually wrapped coils

The DreamCloud Premier has greater thickness at 13 inches that include a pillow top, multiple memory foam layers for comfort and support, and a coil system for support and durability. The most notable design element is the plush pillow top with a complex foam profile for comfort and pressure relief. The pillow-top and extra foam are what makes the DreamCloud feel more luxurious, softer and more plush.

My Hot Take: the Casper Dream feels like a modern hybrid build for support and movement, while the DreamCloud feels like a traditional, luxury hybrid designed for pressure relief and soft comfort.

Firmness and Feel

Even though they both have hybrid designs that combine foam layers on top of coils, they provide different sleep experiences.

We ranked the Casper Dream as closer to a medium-firm mattress of 6/10 during our testing. It felt slightly floaty, buoyant and was notably easy to change positions on. Instead of deep contouring memory foam, you stay on top of the mattress with thin cushioning over strong support. This is a feeling that will serve back sleepers, stomach sleepers and combination sleepers very well.

The DreamCloud Premier is marketed as medium-firm, but in our testing, it felt softer than many other medium-firm hybrids we have tested and we would say it is medium-plush. The initial sensation is plushness, followed by a supportive pushback from the coil system. It doesn’t hug you like an all-foam mattress, but it contours more than the Casper Dream.

Casper Dream and DreamCloud Premier Specs Side-By-Side

Overall, Casper Dream is a more balanced and buoyant hybrid while the DreamCloud Premier is a plusher, thicker sleep surface.

Pressure Relief

This is one area where you can clearly see the difference between the two mattresses. The DreamCloud Premier offers better pressure relief with the pillow-top and thicker foam profile. It felt especially comfortable in the side sleep position and compressed easily under the shoulders and hips, but did not sink so much that you feel stuck.

It is common for side sleepers to need a softer surface to relieve pressure, as side sleeping puts more pressure on the shoulders and hips. 

The Casper Dream had decent pressure relief, but we noticed some stiffness in the shoulders in the morning after spending all night on my side. It’s still soft and comfortable, just not overly plush.

Choose the DreamCloud Premier if pressure relief is your top priority, especially if you are a side sleeper.

Support and Spinal Alignment

The Casper Dream is the clear winner for support and spinal alignment. Hips stayed lifted in the back position and stayed level in the stomach position.

The Zoned Support system delivers on what Casper promises: provides firmer reinforcement through the center of the mattress so your hips and lower back stay lifted.

If you are concerned about back support, read our full article on whether the Casper Dream is good for back pain.

Neutral spinal alignment is important to sleep health and will reduce the possibility of waking up with pain. Back sleeping is the best sleep position to reduce stain in the spine and the Casper Dream performed very well in this sleep position.

The DreamCloud Premier also performed well for support, especially considering how plush it is. The coil layer keeps the hips from dipping too far, even in the back sleeping position. However, it is still softer with not as strong of lift and reinforcement as the Casper.

Cooling Performance

The Casper Dream wins for cooling over the DreamCloud Premier with a 9/10 performance score during our testing. The hybrid design facilitates strong airflow through the coils and the cooling cover helps maintain a neutral temperature through the night.

The DreamCloud Premier sleeps more neutral-cool than a true cool. It showed a lower surface temperature than all-foam mattresses we have tested, but the thicker memory foam layers retain more heat than the Casper Dream. This doesn’t mean it sleeps hot, just that it is less ideal for hot sleepers than the Casper Dream, which is a better pick if you want a mattress that is cooler to the touch.

Motion Isolation

The DreamCloud Premier is the winner for motion isolation, which can be a priority for some couples who are sensitive to motion disturbances.

Casper Dream performed better than most bouncy hybrids in our 10 pound ball drop test, but the DreamCloud Premier was even better. The extra foam also absorbs movement before it bounces back off the coils.

Edge Support

Neither mattress has great edge support during testing, but the DreamCloud is slightly better.

We measured 5 inches of compression while sitting on the edge of the Casper Dream, which is a weak result for a hybrid. The DreamCloud Premier also had deeper compression than expected at about 4.5 inches

Importantly, both mattresses were more stable while lying near the edge instead of sitting, so the surface was strong enough to sleep on without dipping.

Durability and Lifespan

Based on the materials and hybrid construction, both mattresses should last in the 7 to 10 year range.

One callout is that the Casper Dream’s foam is thinner, which may limit the lifespan much beyond 7 years. Less dense foam is more prone to dips and compression at pressure points after years of consistent use.

The real advantage for DreamCloud is that they offer a Forever Warranty, which gives you more protection and confidence for a long lifespan.

Pricing and Value

DreamCloud’s high-quality and luxurious fell make is very compelling for the value it offers, making it the winner on price and value

The Casper Dream price point is fair at around $1,400 – $1,500 for a queen with discount codes, but it is above average for boxed hybrids.

Who Each Mattress Is Best For

Choose Casper Dream if:

• You want a more buoyant, responsive mattress
• You are a stomach sleeper, back sleeper or combination sleeper
• You dislike the body hugging sensation of memory foam
• You sleep warm and want some cooling
• You want strong lumbar support and to keep hips lifted

Choose DreamCloud Premier if:

• You want a plush surface with pressure relief
• You are a side sleeper
• You are a couple and want good motion isolation
• You are budget-conscious and want the best value

Final Verdict: Casper Dream vs DreamCloud Premier

Our Pick: Casper Dream

It was a very close comparison overall between the two mattresses, as each serves different needs better. The Casper Dream is best for a broader range of sleep positions and types of sleepers and provides the stronger support. It is a better mattress for people who want to feel very supported, lifted, cool and be able to move easily on the bed.

The DreamCloud Premier has the best value for the low price. It feels plush, luxurious, provides excellent pressure relief, and is only around $1,000.

Casper Dream vs DreamCloud Premier FAQs

Which mattress is better for side sleepers?

The DreamCloud Premier was more comfortable in the side sleeping position. It is plusher and offers deeper pressure relief in the hips and shoulders. The Casper Dream can still be good for some side sleepers, but has a firmer, more lifted feel, so some may want more cushioning.

Is Casper Dream or DreamCloud Premier better for back pain?

It depends on the type of back pain and the cause. The Casper Dream is better for people who want stronger lumbar support and less sinkage. Additionally, medium firm mattresses, like the Casper Dream, may promote comfort and spinal alignment best.

It also is better for keeping the spine neutral and making you feel lifted. The DreamCloud Premier may feel more comfortable if a softer mattress helps your back pain.

Does Casper Dream sleep cooler than the DreamCloud Premier?

Yes, during our testing the Casper Dream kept a cooler surface temperature after 30 minutes of rest. It has less foam than the DreamCloud Premier, so it does not retain as much heat. The DreamCloud Premier didn’t sleep too warm for a hybrid, but was not as cool as the Casper Dream.

Is DreamCloud Premier worth it over Casper Dream?

The DreamCloud Premier has a lot of value and is priced around $500 less than the Casper Dream. It also has a longer than usual trial of 365 nights and a Forever Warranty. So if you like a softer mattress with a traditional hybrid feel, the DreamCloud is worth it. If you prefer a cooler, more responsive mattress that gives great back support and is comfortable in a variety of sleep positions, the Casper Dream will be worth the higher cost.