Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier

If you are choosing between the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier, it is essentially a choice between a responsive feeling hybrid and a memory foam mattress that offers deep contouring. We slept on both mattresses for 3 nights each and will give you our honest thoughts on how they compare for comfort, support, cooling, value, and who each mattress is best for.

*All images shown are from our real-world testing of both mattresses.

Mattress Millionaires Quick Verdict: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a versatile mattress that is comfortable in multiple sleep positions. It is easy to move on and is an ideal choice for couples and combination sleepers.

For a deeper analysis on its build, feel and testing performance, read our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid review.

The Nectar Premier is an all-foam mattress with 13 inches of various foams for support, cooling and pressure relief. It is an ideal choice for side sleepers and anyone who wants a plush surface and loves the hugging feeling of memory foam.

Here is a quick comparison based on our hands-on testing and individual reviews of each mattress:

Bottom line:

• Choose Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid If you want a breathable, responsive mattress that works for multiple sleep positions.
• Choose Nectar Premier If you want body contouring, pressure relief and minimal partner disturbance.

Who Should Buy Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier?

Buy the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid if you want:

• Plush comfort with underlying support from the coil system
• Better cooling performance from the hybrid design
• Strong edge support for sitting or sleeping near the edge
• A mattress that works across multiple sleep positions (ideal for combination sleepers)
• Strong value for the luxury hybrid category

If you are a heavier weight individual, read our full article on if the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid mattress good for heavy people for our full analysis.

Buy the Nectar Premier if you want:

• Deep pressure relief for side sleeping
• The hugging sensation of memory foam
• Minimal motion transfer for couples
• A slightly lower price point under $1,000

Neither is ideal for:

• Strict stomach sleepers who need very firm alignment
• Very hot sleepers who need advanced cooling features
• People who like a very firm or rigid sleep surface

Mattress Millionaires Scorecard: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier

Here is a side-by-side breakdown on how each mattress ranked after our hands-on testing:

Overall Winner: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Overall, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid performed better in more categories and was more comfortable in multiple sleep positions. The Nectar Premier is a better choice for side sleepers and anyone looking for strong pressure relief.

Firmness and Feel Comparison

The difference in feel between these two mattresses is the most obvious difference. Even though they are both marketed as medium firmness, which is the most popular mattress firmness on the mattress firmness scale.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid feels balanced and responsive. You get a slight plush feeling from the top foam layers, but the coils push back quickly so you feel lifted, not sinking.

The Nectar Premier is the opposite. It’s slower, deeper, and more enveloping. When you lie down, you sink in gradually as the memory foam adapts to your body. This creates excellent pressure relief, but it also makes repositioning harder.

This is one of the most important distinctions: if you don’t like feeling your body being cradled by foam, you probably will not like the Nectar Premier.

Construction and Materials

This comparison is interesting because we are comparing very different mattress types: a hybrid mattress combines foam layers with a coil system for support and airflow, while memory foam mattresses rely entirely on foam for contouring and pressure relief.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

• Quilted top comfort layer
• Responsive TitanFlex foam
• Transitional support foam
• Individually wrapped coils
• High-density base foam

The coil system is the defining feature here. It allows for airflow, responsiveness, and strong support across the mattress.

Nectar Premier

• Cooling quilted cover
• Gel-infused memory foam
• Dynamic support foam
• High-density base foam

Nectar relies entirely on foam layers. That means better contouring and motion isolation—but also more heat retention and less responsiveness.

Pressure Relief

This is where Nectar Premier has the biggest strength and advantage.

The thicker memory foam layers absorb pressure exceptionally well, especially around the shoulders and hips. This is due to how memory foam distributes body weight, which is explained in more detail in studies on how memory foam relieves pressure.

Side sleepers will immediately notice less pressure buildup compared to the Brooklyn Bedding mattress.

Brooklyn Bedding still performs well, but it distributes weight rather than deeply absorbing it. That’s great for back sleepers, but side sleepers may prefer the extra cushioning from Nectar.

Cooling: Which Sleeps Cooler?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the better choice if you are a hot sleeper or just prefer a cooler surface temperature. It sleeps significantly cooler thanks to its coil system that promotes stronger airflow through the mattress, preventing heat retention.

Nectar Premier uses gel-infused foam and a cooling cover, but it still retains more heat. This will be more noticeable if you live in a warmer climate or tend to sleep hot at night.

Overheating at night can reduce deep sleep and increase wakefulness, so it is important to choose a mattress that is cool enough for your sleep style and environment.

Edge Support

Edge support is sometimes overlooked when choosing a mattress, but it matters more than people think, especially if you share the bed with a partner.

Brooklyn Bedding has strong edge support thanks to its coil structure. You can sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’ll slide off.

Nectar Premier has softer edges that compress more easily. It’s stronger than cheaper all-foam mattresses, but deeper compression than the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid.

Durability and Lifespan

Hybrid mattresses tend to last longer, and the Brooklyn Bedding is no exception.

The coil system helps maintain structural integrity over time, reducing sagging. Foam mattresses like Nectar Premier can break down faster, especially under heavier sleepers. The Nectar Premier is very thick and uses a variety of high-density foam, which indicates it should last 7 to 10 years with proper care, though hybrids tend to maintain structure longer term.

Both are solid options, but Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a better choice if you want assurance that it will last 7+ years.

Pricing and Value

Both mattresses offer strong value for a very reasonable price (~$950 for the Nectar Premier / ~$1,299 for the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid).

If you want the lowest price or the best value for a memory foam mattress, go with Nectar Premier. If you’re more interested in pure value and a luxury feel, Brooklyn Bedding is the smarter buy as it offers more features and stronger durability.

Best Sleep Positions

Here is how each mattress performed in different sleep positions during our testing:

Nectar Premier is best for side sleepers because of the plusher top and pressure relief. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is better for back sleepers or combination sleepers. Neither is an ideal choice for stomach sleepers.

Final Verdict: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier

Our overall pick: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid 

We personally loved sleeping on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid and would recommend it to anyone looking for a great value in a premium hybrid mattress that is versatile, responsive and sleeps relatively cool.

Nectar Premier is a strong option for a memory foam mattress that is priced competitively while including high-quality, high-density foam design. If you want the lower price and love the sensation of memory foam, Nectar Premier is a solid option.

FAQs: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid vs Nectar Premier

Which mattress is better for side sleepers?

Nectar Premier is better due to deeper pressure relief.

Which mattress sleeps cooler?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid by a wide margin.

Is Nectar Premier too soft?

For some sleepers – especially stomach sleepers – it can feel too soft.

Which mattress is better for couples?

Nectar Premier has better motion isolation, but Brooklyn Bedding is more versatile overall.

Does Brooklyn Bedding feel like memory foam?

No. It’s more responsive and less contouring.

Is Nectar Premier good for back pain?

It can help with pressure relief, but may lack support for some sleepers.

Which mattress lasts longer?

Brooklyn Bedding generally lasts longer due to its hybrid design.

Is Brooklyn Bedding good for heavy people?

Yes, especially compared to all-foam options.

Does Nectar Premier sleep hot?

It can retain heat more than hybrid mattresses.

Which mattress is easier to move on?

Brooklyn Bedding is significantly easier to move on.

Is Nectar Premier worth the price?

Yes, if you prioritize pressure relief and motion isolation.

Are Brooklyn Bedding and Nectar made in the USA?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is actually manufactured in the United States. It is made at Brooklyn Bedding’s own factory, which is located in Arizona.

This actually helps them control quality, as well as costs. However, Nectar mattresses are designed in the United States – but are actually manufactured overseas.

If domestic manufacturing matters to you, Brooklyn Bedding has the edge in this category.

Which of these two mattresses offers a better trial period and a better warranty?

Brooklyn Bedding offers a pretty great trial period (usually 120 nights), and a 10 year overall warranty.

However, Nectar Premier has one of the best trial offers (and lifetime warranties) in the mattress business. 365 nights for a trial, and a lifetime warranty. This is simply unbeatable.

Which of these two mattresses is better for light sleepers who often wake up?

The hybrid design of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress does allow some motion transfer and bounce, so it may not be the best choice for those who sleep light.

In contrast, the Nectar Premier has truly elite motion isolation- making it a better choice for light sleepers. This is due to the memory foam, which absorbs your movement almost completely.

Do either one of these two mattresses need a box spring?

No, neither of these mattresses require a box spring to use and enjoy them.

In fact, both of these mattresses can be used on:

• adjustable bases
• platform beds
• slatted bases (as long as the spacing is correct)

However, due to the different construction of each mattress, they may benefit from different bases. In particular, the Brooklyn Bedding mattress will likely do better on a sturdy foundation, because of its coil system.

Which of these two mattresses are heavier and more difficult to move?

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is a little bit easier to move and is definitely lighter. The Nectar Premier has 13-inch foam construction – but as a result, is also heavier and more difficult to move.

Which of these two mattresses has less of an off-gassing smell?

Unfortunately, both of these mattresses have some mild off-gassing, but it is not worse than most mattresses.

The Brooklyn Bedding mattress we tested had a shorter-lived odor, and also had an overall lighter smell. In contrast, the Nectar Premier had a little bit more noticeable smell initially – which is mostly due to the dense and thick memory foam layers.

Overall, neither has very bad off-gassing – but the Brooklyn Bedding mattress is a little better in this category.

Can you flip or rotate these mattresses?

Neither mattress is flippable (they are one-sided designs). However, both should be rotated every 3–6 months to promote even wear and extend lifespan.

Which mattress is better for people who move a lot at night?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the better choice. Its responsive foam and coil system make it much easier to reposition, while Nectar’s slow-moving foam can make you feel “stuck” when switching positions.

Which mattress is better for sex?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid performs better due to higher responsiveness, more bounce from coils, and easier movement. Nectar Premier is quieter and more stable, but lacks the same level of responsiveness.

Do these mattresses work with adjustable bases?

Yes, both mattresses are compatible with adjustable bases. However, Nectar Premier’s all-foam construction allows it to conform more closely to the base, while Brooklyn Bedding may feel slightly more rigid due to coils.

Which mattress is better if you sleep with pets or kids?

Nectar Premier is better if movement is the issue because it reduces disturbance. Brooklyn Bedding is better if you need stronger edge support, more usable surface area, and easier movement throughout the night.

Which mattress feels more “premium” in person?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid feels more premium on first impression due to its quilted top, hotel-like plushness, and elevated design aesthetic. Nectar Premier feels premium in a different way – more dense, cushioned, and traditional memory foam luxury.

Will either mattress sag over time?

All mattresses soften over time, but Brooklyn Bedding’s coil system helps maintain structure longer, while Nectar Premier may develop body impressions sooner, especially for heavier sleepers. Rotating the mattress and using a solid foundation will help extend lifespan.

Which mattress is better for guest rooms?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the safer choice for a guest room because it works well for multiple sleep positions and appeals to a wider range of sleepers. Nectar Premier can feel too specific due to its deep memory foam contouring.

Which mattress is better if you’ve never tried memory foam before?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the safer entry point. Nectar Premier’s deep contouring can feel unfamiliar if you are not used to memory foam, while Brooklyn Bedding offers a more balanced and adaptable feel.

Which mattress is best overall?

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the better all-around mattress. Nectar Premier is better for a very specific type of sleeper – those who want deep memory foam comfort.